More Kate? click for >>> Hall of Kate / Kick Inside
Reviewed by Dale Nickey
Ok, here’s the party line on Kate Bush’s second album Lionheart. It was the “difficult second album”; rush released too soon after her stupendous debut, The Kick Inside. The material was under cooked, it was recorded hastily. It was a commercial disappointment. Lionheart has always been viewed as the gawky, homely sister to The Kick Inside. It languishes in the same purgatory as Fleetwood Mac’s Tusk and Michael Jackson’s Bad. Those were all albums that were tasked with following up a monster critical and commercial smash; too much to expect of any mortal record.
However, what if The Kick Inside had never existed, and Lionheart had been her debut? Take away the baggage and the job of reviewing becomes a little more interesting.
Lionheart is not a perfect album yet its still a staggering achievement. Had it been the opening missive in Kate’s discography, jaws would have still dropped just as far. This record is a potent example of the complexity of Kate Bush and her audacious voice, charisma and songs. Had it been her debut, it may not have conferred upon her the instant mantle of “Icon” (as ‘Kick’ did), but that might have been a good thing.
Sure, Lionheart could have benefitted from more time in the bottle or… maybe not. Kate had all the time in the world to worry over The Dreaming. Was it a better record? I’ll let you know when I get around to listening to it as many times as I have Lionheart. Lionheart is a grower that is unique in her canon. Every track on Lionheart earns and rewards repeated visitations.
Let’s get the obvious out of the way. The song “Wow” is a wonderful confection of fantasy/pop. Equal parts torch ballad and bubblegum, it was a smart and successful single that could turn the heads of tabloid writers and music critics alike. And “England, My Lionheart”, is quite simply one of the most beautiful and unique melodies ever written. Usually in pop song craft you can hear echoes of the familiar; even if the artist is stealing from him/herself. This song exists on a different plane. That the lyrics are penned by a teenage girl is stupefying and magical. Why this song hasn’t been declared Britain’s national anthem is beyond me. It still might someday.
The epic “Hammer Horror” could be the subject of an entire review unto itself. By 1978, the term “Rock Opera” had become devalued currency. “Hammer Horror” is definitely a rock opera (albeit a tightly compressed and edited version of the form). Kate whispers, wails, moans and rumbles like both a siren and natural woman. She’s got some burr in her saddle in the form of a stalker, ex-boyfriend, ghost, or some unholy permutation of the three. Whatever happened, it’s now an ever-present nightmare of the soul. The tinkling piano ending turns the neat trick of being pretty and dissonant at the same time. The delayed reaction gong crash signals a melodramatic end to a brilliant and melodramatic record, and the cover art will rock your world.
Elsewhere, things get more eclectic and esoteric. “Coffee Homeground” courts Cabaret and Broadway and elevates both forms. Lead track, “Symphony In Blue” evokes a heavenly cocktail mix of Carol King on ecstasy and helium. On this album, even more than The Kick Inside, Kate takes her voice to its full, death defying limits. Many argue it takes listeners to their limits as well. Like Dylan, Kate’s voice is her signature, money maker, and albatross all rolled into one. One must come to the party prepared to marvel at her athleticism and then dig deep into the music itself. The rewards are there. Kate Bush is not a passive listen. We’ve got Sade for that. No, Lionheart is a three ring circus of emotion, estrogen and technique. And you know what? EMI put it out at just the right time. I’m glad we got two albums documenting Kate’s eloquent, teen dream genius. Soon our little girl would all grow up to be a woman. Lionheart didn’t do anything wrong, it’s just a matter of the paint on her masterpiece hadn’t quite dried yet.
7 responses to “Lost Treasures – Kate Bush (Lionheart Revisited)”
Great review. Always thought LIONHEART was under-rated. I heard it before TKI and following seeing Kate sing “Wow” on an ABBA special broadcast in Detroit, MI. Seeing “Wow” and listening to LH completely hooked me, and I listened to the album–which was given to me by a friend who had been to France–over and over and over in ’79/’80. Anyhow, I agree with you and appreciate you taking up the LH cause!
[…] The Muse Patrol discovers the lost treasure of Lionheart … Vegetable Jam discovers that yes, Kate wrote a song about that … Mallpolis catches 50 Words reviewed on Swedish TV … Who Knew? Mauri Stauffer revisits some of Kate’s work … Tide Music Reviews catch up on 50 Words … Classic Horror Campaign looks at Kate and Night of the Demon … Secret Songbook remembers Delius … Geographer have covered Cloudbusting … My Search for Magic discovers December … Molars chews on Kate … HissyFit gets excited about 50 Words … The Divine Ordinary consider current events and This Woman’s Work … Krystal Difronzo has been preparing a Kate zine … Lewis Pringle finally laid hands on an Aerial vinyl … Prog Archives reviews The Kick Inside … the WomensLiteratureFestival looks at Debi Withers Adventures in Kate Bush and Theory … Catholic Exchange considers The Word and Experiment IV … At Jazz Times Theo Bleckman talks about Kate … The Noise Made by People rather likes Misty … Birmingham Gardeners stop discussing privet hedges and turn to A song of Soloman … a podcast of djbennet’s “Chill Room” tribute to Kate … The Homage Show features Kate … Persephone Magazine looks at Directors Cut and 50 Words … WSSwarts Reviews the Universe but does not like Aerial … Josh Jones discovers a documentary “Kate Bush as Queen of Pop” … BuzzFeed stitches together all Kate’s Fruitopia peices … Scott Heim will release a new ebook on Kate … Too Much Apple Pie remembers Kate on Razzamataz … Richard Metzger’s favourite album is The Dreaming … […]
Lionheart is one of my fav. What about the Kashka from Bagdad?
I actually think it’s better than Never For Ever, which always gets better reviews. The difficult 2nd album was never actually difficult…
You might be right on that. Don’t tell anybody, but I always thought Kate benefited from outside producers. Such as she had on her first two albums. But really she can do no wrong in my book anyway…
I’ve always considered Lionheart as The Kick inside part ll. And I totally agree with the review being these two albums Kate Bush teenage dreams treasure: voice, piano and lyrics. The very definition of originality and raw talent, a masterpiece.
I couldn’t agree more. Lionheart is a terrific album that is usually the first on the worst to best lists of Kate’s records. I bought it as soon as it came out and loved it immediately. I won’t be deterred or influenced by the naysayers. I also love Director’s Cut.